Welcome to Pickle Nickel
At Pickle Nickel, located in charming Dillsburg, PA, we craft a menu full of simple yet delicious comfort food. Our cozy diner vibe invites families and friends to share memorable meals, featuring everything from juicy burgers to hearty subs. Each dish is prepared with fresh ingredients, ensuring quality you can taste—especially our hand-cut fries and must-try fried pickles. Patrons rave about the creative sandwich options, friendly service, and the unique experience of discovering a small arcade for kids. Owned by Kelly, Pickle Nickel embodies a welcoming, small-town spirit that keeps customers returning for more delightful bites.
Pickle Nickel: Reviews & Ratings
Really good food, lots of choices. Small dining room. I think they need better signs. It was hard to find the door. It was worth the trip
If I could give this place more stars I would. The food is simple and tasty. Lots of creative sandwiches and burgers, but also few veggie and seafood options. Fried Pickles are a must, so is Nikki's Laua Burger. Now the bonuses comes in a form of the friendly service and if you have kids, their special is a must. Tokens, what tokens? Was our reaction. And low and behold there is a small arcade tucked away in back. Not only you child will be entertained, but also will leave with a small prise. Win win win. Last but not least. The owner, Kelly, thoughtfully offered us additional coffee refill to-go. The Pickle Nickel is likely will be our "apres ski" destination when skiing in Roundtop.
Adorable smalltown spot with great burgers and simple fun food. Seating is tight. Can't recommend for large parties. Seating is pretty close together, and most seating sits max of 4. Service is simple and personal. Usually only one person behind the desk who handles everything but the cooking, so treat them nice Food was great though, nice juicy burgers, fries are hand cut there in house, not prefrozen crap. They also offer an impressive selection of specialty burgers and sides. Will be happy to go again.
Great little diner in Dillsburg PA. Had the Dillsburger, 4oz. I would recommend the 8 Oz and could use a little more dressing. Great flavor in the meat and really friendly service. Highly recommend.
Somehow I've lived in Dillsburg and have never made it to the Pickle Nickel until yesterday! It was delicious and I can't believe I didn't visit sooner. The french fries were especially good. I got the bacon cheddar ranch fries along with my burger and after writing this review, I want to go get more. Also, the milkshakes are delicious! Make sure you grab one along with your meal.
Dang good burger. I can't believe how thick it was. These days, places have been making smaller burgers. Not this place. The place was pretty busy on a Saturday. There was still plenty of seating. Oh, and how could you not love a place called "Pickle Nickle."
I love this place so so much the owner takes pride in his food and it shows it was so so good. Go here as fast as you can. Im definatly comin back often.
Cute place, that is underestimated. Food was delicious and the atmosphere was nostalgic. Stop by for a great meal.
Location
-
119 N Baltimore St, Dillsburg, PA 17019, United States Hotline: +1 717-432-2112
Welcome to Pickle Nickel!
Nestled in the charming town of Dillsburg, PA, at 119 N Baltimore St, Pickle Nickel is not just a restaurant; it's an experience. The intimate dining space may be small, but it is brimming with character and culinary delight. From the moment you step inside, you are greeted by the friendly faces of the staff who are dedicated to ensuring a memorable meal. The aroma of freshly cooked foods wafts through the air, hinting at the tantalizing dishes that await you.
What Makes Pickle Nickel Stand Out?
- Unique Offerings: Pickle Nickel specializes in a variety of comfort foods that cater to all tastes—from juicy burgers to savory seafood options. One must-try highlight is Cody's Surf & Turf, featuring a pub-style crab cake perched atop a delectable sirloin burger, all for just $13.95. For those craving seafood, don’t miss the Captain Dave's Fish & Chips—crispy beer-battered haddock served with fries for $14.95.
- Family-Friendly Vibes: The kids aren't neglected either! With a kid's menu that includes classic favorites like grilled cheese and mini burgers, it's a perfect spot for families. And, for the little ones, there's a delightful arcade tucked away at the back, adding an element of fun to the dining experience.
- Homemade Goodness: Customers rave about the hand-cut fries, a testament to the eatery's commitment to serving high-quality, homemade meals. Pair them with the tantalizing bacon cheddar ranch fries for an indulgent treat that leaves you wanting more.
- Creative Sandwiches: The menu is bursting with creativity, boasting an array of specialty burgers and sandwiches. Be sure to try the Nikki's Luau Burger or the veggie burger sub for a delightful twist on classic flavors.
Customer feedback speaks volumes about the dining experience at Pickle Nickel. One satisfied patron, Max Rapoport, expresses appreciation for the simple but delicious food, highlighting the friendly service and the unexpected joy of leaving with tokens from the arcade. Another customer, Seth Miller, wishes he had visited sooner, raving about the utterly delicious milkshakes and crispy fries. It’s clear: when you dine at Pickle Nickel, you're not just enjoying a meal; you're creating memories.
If you’re looking for a laid-back spot to enjoy hearty food with loved ones, Pickle Nickel stands out as a perfect choice. With an inviting atmosphere, attentive service, and a menu that delights the taste buds, it's no wonder this local gem is quickly becoming a favorite among residents and visitors alike. So, whether you're stopping by after a day on the slopes or simply in search of comfort food, make your way to Pickle Nickel—you won't be disappointed.