Pickle Nickel Menu

Introducing the Menu at Pickle Nickel

Located in the charming town of Dillsburg, PA, Pickle Nickel presents a delectable menu that highlights its 100% sirloin specialty burgers. Here, culinary creativity meets comfort food, offering a memorable dining experience for all ages. Signature items like the Michele's Bacon Luvah and Cody's Surf and Turf showcase bold flavors, while the Greek Feta Burger caters to those seeking a twist on the classic.

  • Fried Pickles paired with ranch dressing are a must-try!
  • Kids can enjoy mini burgers and hot dogs, all at pocket-friendly prices.
  • The cozy atmosphere and friendly service make it perfect for families.

With an atmosphere that feels like home, Pickle Nickel promises satisfying meals and a touch of nostalgia, making it a beloved treasure for locals and visitors alike.

100% Sirloin Specialty Burgers

Pickle Nickel

$12.95

Cassie Bleu

4oz 8.95, 8oz 15.95

Greek Feta Burger

4oz 7.95, 8oz 11.95

Cody's Surf and Turf

$13.95

The Polar Bear

4oz 7.95, 8oz 11.95

Hot Mama

4oz 7.95, 8oz 11.95, Chicken 9.95

Jess's Steakhouse Burger

4oz 7.95, 8oz 12.95, Chicken 9.95

Chunk Norris

4oz 7.95, 8oz 11.95, Chicken 9.95

Tombstone

4oz 8.95, 8oz 13.95

Michele's Bacon Luvah

$15.95

Hamburger

4oz 6.50, 8oz 9.50, Chicken 8.25

Cheeseburger

4oz 6.75, 8oz 9.75, Chicken 8.50

Bacon Cheeseburger

4oz 7.50, 8oz 10.50, Chicken 9.25

Mushroom Swiss

4oz 7.25, 8oz 10.25, Chicken 9.50

Hickory BBQ

4oz 7.75, 8oz 10.75, Chicken 9.50

Pepperoni Pizza Burger

4oz 7.75, 8oz 10.75, Chicken 9.50

Dillsburger

4oz 7.00, 8oz 10.00, Chicken 8.75

Butch's Buffalo Burger

4oz 7.75, 8oz 10.75, Chicken 9.50

Taco Burger

4oz 7.25, 8oz 10.25, Chicken 9.00

Ken's Chili Cheeseburger

4oz 7.75, 8oz 10.75

Handmade 100% Sirloin Burgers

SUBS

HAMBURGER SUB

Hamburger, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, mayo

$8.00

CHEESEBURGER SUB

Cheeseburger, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, mayo

$8.25

BACON CHEESEBURGER SUB

Bacon cheeseburger, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, mayo

$8.75

SIRLOIN STEAK SUB

Chopped sirloin, sauteed onion, cheese sauce

$8.25

CHICKEN CHEESESTEAK

With 100% white meat chicken breast, sautéed onions, cheese sauce

$9.95

VEGGIE BURGER SUB

Veggie burger, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, mayo

$9.00

GRILLED CHEESE

$3.50

GRILLED CHEESE & TOMATO

$4.75

GRILLED CHEESE & BACON

$5.75

CHICKEN STRIPS

Ranch, Buffalo wing sauce hot or mild, honey mustard, BBQ

$6.95

OTHER CHOICES

HOT DOGS

HOT DOG

$3.25

CHEESE DOG

$4.25

CHILI CHEESE DOG

$5.25

KIM'S CHEEZY BARKER

Grilled cheese w/a hot dog inside

$5.75

BACON CHEESE DOG

$6.75

THE INFAMOUS JOE DOG

Mild Chili, Fine Diced Red Onion (Lite Ketchup, Lite Mustard Recommended)

$5.75

HOUSE SALAD

Diced tomatoes, onions, shredded cheddar, croutons, dressing

$7.50

CHICKEN CAESAR

Grilled or fried chicken, parmesan cheese, croutons, Caesar dressing

$12.50

SOUTHWESTERN CHICKEN

Grilled or fried BBQ chicken, corn, black beans, diced tomatoes, onions, cheddar cheese, tortilla strips, ranch dressing

$12.50

GREEK CHICKEN

Grilled or fried chicken, black olives, feta cheese, onions, greek dressing

$11.50

BLEU CHEESE CHICKEN

Grilled or fried chicken, bleu cheese crumbles, crumbled bacon, onions, diced tomatoes, croutons, bleu cheese dressing

$14.50

TACO

Taco seasoned sirloin, salsa, diced tomatoes, cheddar cheese, tortilla strips, mild taco sauce, sour cream

$13.50

CRABCAKE CAESAR

Pub style crabcake served on top of a Caesar salad

$15.50

BUFFALO CHICKEN

Grilled or fried buffalo (hot or mild) chicken, bacon, bleu cheese crumbles, diced tomatoes, bleu cheese dressing

$13.50

CRISPY SPUDBOY SALAD

FRIED chicken, shredded cheddar, tomatoes, onion, topped w/fries, ranch dressing

$12.50

FRESH, MADE TO ORDER SALADS

FRESH CUT FRENCH FRIES-Gluten Free.

SMALL

$3.95

LARGE

$4.95

CHEESE FRIES

$6.45

CHILI CHEESE FRIES

$7.95

GRAVY FRIES

$6.45

PICKLE NICKEL FRIES

Topped w/bacon, sautéed HOT banana peppers and melted cheese

$8.95

BACON, BLEU CHEESE, BUFFALO FRIES

Topped w/bleu cheese crumbles, bacon crumbles, hot or mild Buffalo sauce

$8.95

BACON, CHEESE & RANCH

Topped w/bacon crumbles, melted cheese, ranch dressing

$7.95

JOSH'S TACO FRIES-DINE IN ONLY

Topped w/chili, sour cream, lettuce, black olives, cheese, onions, diced tomatoes

$10.95

ONION RINGS

$3.95

FRIED PICKLES

Served with ranch dressing

$6.75

MOZZARELLA STIX

Served with pizza sauce

$6.75

SIDES SAMPLER

4 Onion rings, 2 mozzarella stix, 2 fried pickles, 2 chix strips

$11.95

OTHER SIDES

BILL MACKS HOMEMADE ICE CREAM

PER SCOOP

$3.50

MILKSHAKE

Vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, peanut butter, chocolate peanut butter, orange creamsicle, black raspberry, oreo cookie, caramel, caramel mocha

$4.75

FLOAT OR MALT

$5.95

BOTTLED BEVERAGES

Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Root Beer, Dr. Pepper, Sweet Tea, Unsweetened Tea, Lemonade

$2.25

6 OZ BEER BATTERED HADDOCK SANDWICH

$11.95

CAPTAIN DAVE'S FISH & CHIPS BASKET

6 oz beer battered haddock with fries

$14.95

CRABCAKE SANDWICH

$10.25

CODY'S SURF & TURF

Pub style crab cake on top of sirloin burger topped w/bacon

$13.95

SEAFOOD

FOR OUR HERBIVORE FRIENDS

VEGGIE BURGER

$8.00

VEGGIE BURGER SUB

Veggie burger, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, mayo

$9.00

VEGGIE BURGER WRAP

SEE WRAP SECTION

$9.50

HOT DOG

$3.25

CHEESE DOG

$4.25

CHICKEN STRIPS

Ranch, BBQ, Buffalo wing sauce hot or mild, honey mustard

$6.95

GRILLED CHEESE

$3.50

MINI BURGER

$3.50

MINI CHEESEBURGER

$3.75

FOR THE KIDS

WRAPS-White or wheat tortilla

CHICKEN CAESAR

Grilled or fried chicken, romaine lettuce, shredded parmesan cheese, Caesar dressing

$9.50

BUFFALO CHICKEN

Grilled or fried chicken, romaine lettuce, shredded cheddar cheese, tomatoes, hot or mild buffalo sauce

$10.50

GREEK CHICKEN

Grilled or fried chicken, romaine lettuce, black olives, onions, feta cheese crumbles, greek dressing

$9.50

BLEU CHEESE CHICKEN

Grilled or fried chicken, romaine lettuce, bleu cheese crumbles, bacon, onions, tomatoes, bleu cheese dressing

$10.95

CHICKEN TACO

Grilled or fried chicken, taco seasoning, romaine lettuce, shredded cheddar cheese, salsa, diced tomatoes, sour cream

$10.50

SANTA FE CHICKEN

Grilled or fried BBQ chicken, romaine lettuce, corn, black beans, shredded cheddar cheese, onions, diced tomatoes, ranch dressing

$9.95

VEGGIE BURGER WRAP

Choose any of the above wraps and substitute chicken w/a veggie burger

$9.50